Episodes
| Episode | Title | First Broadcast | Repeated | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01 | Trans Rights And Free Speech | 20220624 | Trans Ri | In an era of polarisation, propaganda, and pile-ons, AntiSocial offers an alternative: understanding, facts, and respect. Each week, host of the BBC's Newscast Adam Fleming takes on a topic that's generating conflict and seeks out challenging perspectives and illuminating context. We can't end the fighting, but we can tell you how it started, why it started - and help you work out what the arguments of our times are really about. Why is the conversation about trans rights and women's rights so toxic? This week, two sports governing bodies decided that trans women should not compete in women's categories. Other sports announced they would review their policies. There's a row about that, but beneath that is a deeper argument about how the tensions around gender identity are discussed and debated. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Lucy Proctor & Simon Maybin Researcher: Ellie House Music: Oskar Jones Editor: Emma Rippon |
| 02 | White Privilege And Schools | 20220701 | Taking on hot issues with cool heads, presented by Adam Fleming. This week, parents are voicing concerns about the way the concept of white privilege is being taught in schools. How did the conversation about white privilege go mainstream in the UK? Where did it come from? The BBC's Home Editor Mark Easton shares some data on the experiences of different ethnic groups in Britain. And a teacher grapples with whether you can tell poor pupils that they're actually privileged. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Lucy Proctor & Simon Maybin Researcher: Ellie House & Octavia Woodward Production coordinator: Brenda Brown Studio Manager: Hal Haines Music: Oskar Jones Editor: Emma Rippon How the concept of white privilege is being taught in schools. | |
| 03 | Cars And The Climate | 20220708 | The battle between gas-guzzlers and environmentalists. Motorists have been staging go-slow protests on motorways over how expensive it is to get everywhere. Meanwhile, environmental protestors have been letting down the tyres of the biggest gas-guzzlers to stop them going anywhere. They want people to give up their cars, but drivers don't like being told what to do. It's getting people angry on social media. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin & Lucy Proctor Researchers: Ellie House & Octavia Woodward Production Coordinator: Brenda Brown Studio Manager: Hal Haines Music: Oskar Jones Editor: Emma Rippon R4 | |
| 04 | Free Speech And Online Harm | 20220715 | Hopefuls for the Conservative Party leadership have been talking about the Online Safety Bill. One candidate said the planned attempt to make tech companies do something about content that is legal but harmful amounts to ?legislating for hurt feelings'. And social media had a lot to say. A comedian and an academic discuss. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Chloe Hadjimatheou & Lucy Proctor Researchers: Ellie House & Octavia Woodward Production Coordinator: Brenda Brown Studio Manager: Chris Murphy Music: Oskar Jones Editor: Emma Rippon Fears that clamping down on online harm means censorship. | |
| 05 | Gaslighting And Relationships | 20220722 | Love Island has sparked debate about gaslighting and narcissism. The reality TV show Love Island has once again ignited discussion about the way men treat women in relationships. Two domestic violence charities called out what they called gaslighting and coercive control. Meanwhile on social media a wider conflict about these new terms has rumbled on. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Josephine Casserly & Lucy Proctor Researcher: Ellie House Production Coordinator: Brenda Brown Studio Manager: Hal Haines Music: Oskar Jones Editor: Emma Rippon | |
| 06 | Race And Representation | 20220729 | The England women's football team has been on our screens a lot, but the team has attracted criticism for only fielding white players in the quarter finals. That sparked a discussion around what the right levels of representation should be on screen and in public life. Is it true that you can't be what you can't see? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin & Lucy Proctor Researchers: Ellie House and Octavia Woodward Production Coordinator: Brenda Brown Studio Manager: Chris Murphy Music: Oskar Jones Editor: Emma Rippon Are ethnic minorities fairly represented in public life? | |
| 07 | Drag Queens And Libraries | 20220805 | The row over drag queens reading stories to children. A spate of protests outside libraries has focused attention on the idea of drag queen story hours - drag queens reading stories to young children in libraries and other public spaces. For some, it's the perfect way to build acceptance of LGBTQ+ identities, plus it's fun and fabulous for the children. For others, it risks exposing young minds to adult entertainment and complex themes of sex and gender. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin & Lucy Proctor Researcher: Ellie House Music: Oskar Jones Editor: Hugh Levinson | |
| 08 | Online Justice And Rape | 20220812 | Rape allegations about a footballer have led to debate online and protests in real life. A woman who says she was raped by a Premier League footballer put her allegations and evidence for them online. On social media some people have tried to pick holes in her account and demanded anonymity for people accused of rape. Others are outraged that the player hasn't been suspended by his club. In real life, an aeroplane banner protest said `Kick rapists off the pitch??. What's the law on identifying rape suspects? How common are false allegations of rape? And do people actually understand the law on rape? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin & Lucy Proctor Researcher: Ellie House Production co-ordinators: Maria Ogundele & Helena Warwick-Cross Music: Oskar Jones Editors: Hugh Levinson & Penny Murphy | |
| 09 | Fast Fashion And Class | 20220819 | The argument about whether shopping 'sustainably' is a privilege not everyone can afford. People online are debating whether contestants from ITV's Love Island should be signing mega-bucks deals with clothes companies that sell people stuff cheaply and often - so-called fast fashion. Others claim it's a bit rich for the well-off to lecture everyone else about what's in their wardrobe? We'll look at how fast fashion got turbo-charged, see if the stats on climate change and fashion add up, explore how fashion and social class have interacted over the years, and ask if `sustainable fashion?? is an oxymoron. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin & Josephine Casserly Researcher: Ellie House Production co-ordinator: Brenda Brown Music: Oskar Jones Editor: Emma Rippon | |
| 10 | Trigger Warnings | 20220826 | Upsetting content' warnings at universities: a harmless courtesy or oversensitivity? Some higher education institutions are accused of 'wokery' and pandering to 'snowflake' students because texts now sometimes come with notes saying some students may find the content distressing. People in favour of such warnings see them as an unintrusive way of respecting students' mental well-being. But what does 'triggering' actually mean? What do students think about trigger warnings? How did they end up on university campuses? And do they actually work? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin & Josephine Casserly Researcher: Octavia Woodward Production co-ordinator: Brenda Brown Music: Oskar Jones Editor: Emma Rippon | |
| 11 | 'woke' Police | 20220902 | woke Police | Accusations that the police are spending time dancing the Macarena at Pride parades instead of controlling crime stepped up this week following a report by a think tank. Critics say the police are being political by taking the knee at Black Lives Matter marches and prioritising policing Twitter over policing the streets. Others say community engagement is key and that it's all about resources. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin & Lucy Proctor Researchers: Ellie House & Octavia Woodward Production co-ordinator: Jacqui Johnson Music: Oskar Jones Editor: Emma Rippon The criticism of dancing police officers and rainbow police cars. |
| 12 | Milk And Protestors | 20220923 | Direct action against dairies, animal cruelty, and the climate crisis. Animal Rebellion protestors have blockaded dairies, making the case for a ?plant-based future??. They say the dairy industry is a key contributor to the climate crisis and is based on cruelty and exploitation. Online, opponents say they want to choose what they eat and that the direct action is counter-productive. Are the claims made by protesters true? And why is milk such a touchy subject in this country? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin & Lucy Proctor Researchers: Ellie House & Octavia Woodward Production co-ordinator: Jacqui Johnson Music: Oskar Jones Editor: Emma Rippon | |
| 13 | Harry And Meghan | 20230113 | The revelations in Prince Harry's book Spare have dominated the news and the nation's conversations, with many people taking sides. For some, Harry and Meghan represent a couple who speak their truth and challenge racism, sexism and attitudes towards mental health. For others, they have betrayed their family and are emblematic of a privileged, navel-gazing world view. Why have the Duke and Duchess of Sussex become such symbols? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Lucy Proctor, Phoebe Keane and Ellie House Editor: Emma Rippon Prince Harry's autobiography is dividing the nation. In an era of polarisation, propaganda and pile-ons, AntiSocial offers an alternative: understanding, facts, and respect. Each week, Adam Fleming takes on a topic - something from the news - that's generating conflict on social media, blogs, talk shows and phone-ins and helps you work out what the arguments are really about. Producer: Lucy Proctor | |
| 14 | Brit Awards And Gender | 20230120 | The Brit Awards were gender neutral for the second time this year - which meant there was no best male or best female artist award. Over the last week the reaction to the all-male nomination list for Best Artist has been fierce, with many women outraged at the lack of female representation. Is the music industry ready for gender neutrality? Does inclusivity come at the expense of women? Presenter: Victoria Derbyshire Producers: Lucy Proctor, Phoebe Keane and Ellie House Editor: Emma Rippon | |
| 15 | Neurodiversity And Autism | 20230127 | What is neurodiversity and how has it changed the way we talk about autism? Is it always helpful for people who are autistic and their families? As video app Tik Tok became more and more popular, so too did the use of #Neurodivergent. Videos using this hashtag have racked up 6.6 billion views. Many people who are autistic use this hashtag when posting positive experiences, to help improve understanding amongst their followers. But some say that social media is fuelling an epidemic of people self-diagnosing and that this is damaging for autistic people. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Lucy Proctor, Phoebe Keane and Ellie House Editor: Emma Rippon | |
| 16 | Trans Women And Prisons | 20230203 | The Scottish Prison Service is under fire for sending a trans woman who raped two women to a female prison. That has brought the ongoing battle about whether trans women should be in women's prisons to the top of the social media agenda. Some argue that men's prisons are not safe for trans women. But others say that biological males should never be in women's prisons. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Lucy Proctor, Phoebe Keane and Ellie House Editor: Emma Rippon The row over a trans woman convicted of rape sent to a women's prison in Scotland. | |
| 17 | Delilah And Cancelling Songs | 20230210 | A row over whether it's appropriate for the Tom Jones classic song Delilah to be sung at Welsh Rugby matches because it depicts violence against women. Some claim that domestic violence spikes around rugby matches, making the song even more inappropriate. Others point to the long British and American tradition of songs about murder and question whether a song can provoke domestic abuse. Should we impose modern values on culture from the past? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Lucy Proctor, Phoebe Keane, Ellie House and Octavia Woodward. Editor: Emma Rippon Calls for rugby fans to stop singing Delilah. | |
| 18 | 15-minute Cities And Freedom | 20230217 | How talk of low traffic neighbourhoods and traffic filters became a heated debate about freedom. When Oxfordshire county council announced plans to implement six traffic filters across the city, it caused such controversy that even people in America were posting on social media about the restrictions they might impose. The council said they received death threats due to the misinformation swirling online, often from people outside of Oxford. So why have the discussions online become so heated? How talk of traffic restrictions in Oxford became a heated debate about freedom. | |
| 19 | Asylum Seekers And The Far Right | 20230224 | Thousands of asylum seekers are currently housed in hotels around the UK as they wait for their claims to be processed. The government has a huge backlog and are spending millions of pounds a day on the accommodation. Local residents have started to mount protests near the hotels, prompting claims from commentators and counter-protestors that they are 'far right'. What does that term mean? Are these protestors really 'far right'. And to what extent is the extreme right on the rise across the country? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Lucy Proctor, Phoebe Keane, Ellie House and Octavia Woodward. Editor: Emma Rippon Protestors about asylum seekers in hotels have been called 'far right'. | |
| 20 | Body Positivity And Fat | 20230303 | The word 'fat' has been removed from a new range of Roald Dahl books. It's a sign our conversation about obesity and body image has become increasingly sensitive. Many body positivity activists have reclaimed the word 'fat' while promoting more diversity in the body shapes and sizes we see in our media. But some accuse the movement of denying the health risks associated with being overweight. Is it true we can be healthy at any size? Where did the body positivity movement come from? And should we be worried about the return of size 0 fashion? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Lucy Proctor, Phoebe Keane and Ellie House. Editor: Emma Rippon The body positivity movement is accused of promoting obesity. | |
| 21 | Blasphemy Laws And Free Speech | 20230310 | The cover of a Quran was torn in a school in Wakefield, Yorkshire and four students were suspended. The next day, police were called after the boy involved in the incident received death threats. It lead to debate online about whether our laws should protect religious people from offence, or should uphold free speech. We'll get to the bottom of what went on and explore how you balance respect for religion with free speech? How do you balance respect for religion with free speech? | |
| 22 | Sex Education And Schools | 20230317 | After sex education was made compulsory in England in 2019, many schools started bringing in external companies to teach the subject. But with no formal regulation, a vast range of lessons are being offered and some providers refuse to let parents know what's being taught. It's led to some misinformation spreading online and a debate about whether some things are too explicit to learn at school. Archive from British Pathe, David Rosler via the British Film Institute and the Netflix series Sex Education. Some school pupils are learning about pleasure, and parents think it's too explicit. | |
| 23 | Covid Vaccines And Misinformation | 20230324 | A speech by Andrew Bridgen MP about Covid vaccines was taken down from YouTube after accusations it contained misinformation. It's led to a debate about where freedom of speech ends and misinformation begins. What counts as misinformation? And who decides? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Lucy Proctor, Phoebe Keane and Ellie House. Editor: Emma Rippon An MP's speech about Covid vaccines was removed from YouTube for alleged misinformation. | |
| 24 | Cultural Appropriation And Afro Wigs | 20230331 | Abba fans were asked not to wear Afro wigs over claims they are 'culturally insensitive'. | |
| 25 | Barbie And The Patriarchy | 20230728 | 20230802 (R4) | What is 'the patriarchy' and does it still exist in the UK today? The Barbie movie's portrayal of the patriarchy and a world in which men have all the positions of power has triggered debate on social media around whether the UK is a patriarchal society. According to Barbie's friend Ken, patriarchy is when ?men on horses run everything?. According to history, Marxist scholars first described the patriarchy as a system that favoured men over women and characterised it as integral part of the capitalist system. Years later, in the 1970s, it became a focal point for feminist activists who campaigned for equal rights and representation for women. In Britain today, though, when many of the laws that gave more power to men have been overturned, is there still a system in place that gives men more power than women? Is the word useful? We explain the history of the phrase and fact-check the ways in which people across the debate measure gender equality. Contributors: Charlotte Proudman, campaigner and barrister specialising in gender based violence cases Mike Bell, creator of the website Equi-law which researches disadvantages experienced by men and boys Lucy Delap, Professor of Modern British and Gender History at the University of Cambridge Kelly Beaver, CEO for UK & Ireland at Ipsos |
| 26 | 'woke' Capitalism | 20230804 | 20230809 Woke Capitalism 20230809 (R4) | Should companies weigh-in on sensitive social issues? After a Costa Coffee van featured artwork of a trans man with mastectomy scars, there have been calls to boycott the chain on social media. And there's been controversy over banks rejecting customers because of their political views. Are businesses trying to make the world better or just more money? And is it the place of companies to fight what they see as social injustice? Guests: Lucy McKillop, CEO of OutVertising Ben Habib, former MEP for the Brexit Party and CEO of a property investment fund management firm Aileen McColgan, barrister specialising in discrimination law Xinrong Zhu, assistant professor in marketing, Imperial College London Business School Daniel Korschun, Associate Professor and Marketing Department Head at Drexel University in Philadelphia |
| 27 | Hard Work And Mental Health | 20230811 | 20230816 (R4) | Is better awareness of mental illness a good thing - or encouraging people out of work? A newspaper columnist questioned whether a rise in people out of work because of bad mental health might include some who could have ?soldiered on?? It reignited a discussion online about the benefits of work and the importance of emotional wellbeing. On one side are those who think a better understanding of mental health is a necessary correction following decades of neglect. On the other, people who say all the talk of conditions like depression and anxiety has become a self-fulfilling prophecy. What's the evidence? Guests: Dr Jay Watts, Consultant clinal psychologist Gillian Bridge, author and former addiction counsellor Andy Bell, CEO of Centre for Mental Health Ann John, professor of public health and psychiatry, Swansea University Darren Morgan, Director of Economic Statistics Production & Analysis at the Office for National Statistics |
| 28 | 'queering' Museums | 20230818 | queering Museums 20230823 (R4) | The debate sparked by reviewing historic collections through a queer or LGBT lens. A ?queering the collection? blogpost from the Mary Rose Museum in Portsmouth was criticised for making what some saw as tenuous links between historic objects from the ship and the experience of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer people. Supporters of ?queering? museums and galleries say it's needed to redress a traditional approach to history that has often ignored non-heterosexual people or stories. But it's led to controversy and criticism that some institutions have gone too far by focusing on the LGBT angle at the expense of others or imposing a modern interpretation that wouldn't have made sense at the time. Guests: Dominique Bouchard, Head of Learning and Interpretation at English Heritage Mary Harrington, Contributing Editor at UnHerd Jackie Stacey, Professor of Media and Cultural Studies at the University of Manchester. Josh Adair, Professor of English at Murray State University |
| 29 | Can White People Be Victims Of Racism? | 20230825 | 20230830 (R4) | The argument about prejudice, power, and the disputed idea of ?reverse racism?. A design guide from the Mayor of London's office included a photo of a white family along with the caption ?Doesn't represent real Londoners?. A spokesman for Mayor Sadiq Khan said the text was ?added by a staff member in error?, but some on social media said it showed City Hall was racist against white people. What was actually in the guide? Where does the concept of racism come from? And what does the law say about whether white people can be victims of racism? Guests: Rakib Ehsan, researcher, writer, and commentator specialising in immigration and integration Jaya Gordon-Moore, teacher of A-level Criminology and rapper (JayaHadADream) M?nica Moreno Figueroa, Professor of Sociology at the University of Cambridge Mike Walters, Professor of Criminal Law and Criminology at the University of Sussex The argument about prejudice, power, and the disputed idea of reverse racism. |
| 30 | Jewish Actors For Jewish Roles? | 20230901 | 20230906 (R4) | The debate about whether Jewish characters should always be played Jewish actors. The actor Bradley Cooper is playing Leonard Bernstein, the conductor and composer of many works, including West Side Story. Bradley Cooper, who isn't Jewish, wears a prosthetic nose as part of his portrayal. The Bernstein family were consulted on the film and say they're ?perfectly fine' with it. But it's prompted a debate about whether non-Jewish actors should play Jewish roles. Is it always problematic for an actor to wear a fake nose due to the history of negative caricatures? Should casting be based simply on someone's acting ability? Guests: Rebecca Wilson, actor Josh Kaplan, Head of digital at the Jewish Chronicle Bryan Cheyette, Professor of English Literature at Reading University Danny Stone, CEO, AntiSemitism Policy Trust The debate about whether Jewish characters should always be played by Jewish actors. |
| 31 | Counting Sexual Partners | 20230908 | Counting Sexual Partners 20230913 (R4) | ' Does your sexual history matter, and is it relevant whether you're a man or a woman? A viral tweet criticised a woman for having a high 'body count' - a term used to describe how many sexual partners a person has had. It's a popular topic on platforms like TikTok, where some people boast about their big numbers, but others are critical of people with high body counts. Claims that women are less attractive if they've slept with lots of people have led to arguments about double standards and sexism. We look at how this debate emerged, the origins of 'slut-shaming,' and what we know about how many sexual partners the average Briton has had. |
| 32 | Political Symbols At Work | 20231110 | 20231115 (R4) | AKA Political Symbols And Work A photo that appeared to show an NHS healthcare worker wearing a Palestine badge caused a heated debate on social media. Some say during the current conflict between Israel and Hamas, the Palestine flag becomes a political symbol and therefore breaches the principal that NHS staff should appear to be impartial. Others point to a double standard and question why the poppy can be worn by state sector workers even though some believe it is a political symbol. What counts as 'political' and how free should we feel in the workplace to express our beliefs? Should we be free to wear any political symbol at work? The row over whether NHS staff should be able to wear a Palestine badge and what counts as a 'political' symbol. |
| 33 | The 'digital Pound' | 20231117 | 20231122 (R4) | A clip from the European Central Bank, talking about progress towards an electronic version of the euro, has sparked concern on social media. Some suggest new central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) like this - including a digital pound under consideration in the UK - are designed to track our spending, or even restrict it. And there are fears it could lead to the elimination of cash altogether. But others say CBDCs are a recognition of cash's decline, providing an alternative, and that central banks need to keep up with changing financial technologies. So what exactly is a digital pound, how would people use it, and how different is it to the way we pay for things now? Would you swap cash for a central bank digital currency? Central banks in the UK and elsewhere are considering digital versions of their currencies, but some fear it could lead to restrictions on how we spend our money. |
| 34 | Lawyers: 'lefty' Or Right? | 20231124 | 20231129 (R4) 20240329 (R4) | The debate around so-called 'lefty lawyers'. After the government's Rwanda asylum policy was found to be unlawful by the Supreme Court, lots of people on social media started to say this was down to so-called 'lefty lawyers'. Some say using legal challenges to override government policy is undemocratic. Others say it's important to hold the government to account and ensure politicians stick to the laws they write. Lawyers also push back on being called either left or right wing, as they are just acting on behalf of their client, no matter their personal views. The debate around so-called 'lefty lawyers'. What's behind the use of the phrase? The debate around the use of the phrase 'lefty lawyers'. What's behind the phrase, who uses it, and why? |
| 35 | Is Reality Tv Stereotyping Black Women? | 20231201 | 20231206 (R4) | Nella Rose, a black woman on the reality TV show 'I'm a Celebrity...Get Me Out of Here!' has divided opinion online - some accuse her of being rude and aggressive in the Australian jungle, while others say she's the victim of racism and misogyny. We explore some of the comments made about her and examine the history, meaning and potential real-world symptoms of 'misogynoir' - a theory about a combination of racism and sexism faced by black women. Plus, are the casting directors and editors of reality TV shows guilty of stereotyping black women as rude and aggressive, and what evidence is there of racism amongst the viewing and voting public? A contestant on the TV show I'm a Celebrity sparks a debate about racism and misogyny. A contestant on the TV show I'm a Celebrity...Get Me Out of Here sparks a debate about racism and misogyny - is British reality TV guilty of 'misogynoir'? |
| 36 | Trans Kids And Schools | 20231208 | 20231213 (R4) | What should teachers do if a pupil wants to use a name, uniform, toilet or changing room of the opposite sex because they feel it better represents who they are? It's known as 'social transitioning'. It's in the news because the former Prime Minister Liz Truss has proposed a new law that would ban it in schools - re-charging a debate that's been going on from a while. Social transitioning isn't the same as having surgery or taking drugs. So what is it? Schools have been crying out for some guidance from the government. We'll hear what teachers have been doing in the meantime. There are laws that protect pupils and laws that protect teachers. We'll find out where they sometimes clash. How schools should deal with kids who want to change their gender identity. The debate about how schools should deal with kids who want to change their gender identity and 'socially transition'. |
| 37 | The National Anthem | 20231215 | 20231020 20231220 (R4) | Bristol University has dropped the national anthem from some of its graduation ceremonies, sparking a discussion about the song's relevance to students and the merits of the national anthem more broadly. The university made the change in 2020 and will now sing God Save the King' at just two ceremonies a year, when a representative of the royal family attends. So why has it sparked a heated discussion this week? Some say the national anthem is too focused on the monarch, which represents an outdated way of running the state and reminds us of a problematic past. Others say it's an important tradition, we have much to be proud of and there is too much snobbishness about displaying national pride. Our panel discuss their views and we consider what a new anthem might sound like. We hear that the anthem originates from a turbulent time for the monarchy. Pollsters at More in Common explain that a small group of the population that are most likely to dislike the monarchy are also the most likely to write political social media posts, giving them a disproportionate say in the debate. The debate about whether we should sing God Save the King. The debate about whether university students should sing the national anthem and whether we should choose a new one. |
| 38 | Culture Wars In Europe | 20231222 | 20231227 (R4) | An AntiSocial special, charting the culture wars across Europe. In Italy, there's a battle over surrogacy - bringing into question the rights of same-sex couples, the exploitation of women, and the influence of the Church. In Spain, more than half the country thinks that men are being discriminated against with the push for women's equality. And across borders, both progressive and conservative activists are creating international networks to spread their message. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producer: Ellie House Reporter: Sofia Bettiza Researcher: Thomas Farmer Editor: Richard Vadon Studio Managers: Graham Puddifoot and Matt Cadman Production Coordinators: Janet Staples and Katie Morrison Surrogacy in Italy, feminism in Spain, and culture wars activism across borders. In Italy, there's a battle over surrogacy. Meanwhile in Spain, 53% think feminism has gone too far. How are these fights playing out, and how do they spread across borders? |
| 39 | 'black Out' Performances | 20240308 | 20240313 (R4) | A theatre production dealing with race issues has been criticised after announcing plans to stage some of its performances for primarily black audiences. The so-called ?Black Out? nights are scheduled for two dates of Slave Play?s West End run. Some have labelled the move divisive and unnecessary, and even Downing Street has got involved. The show?s playwright and producers say they?re aiming to bring new audiences to the theatre and allow black people to watch it without the ?white gaze?. But what does this term mean, what are the origins of Black Out performances, and is this a concept that?s applicable to other minority groups? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Ellie House, Sandra Kanthal, Simon Tulett Editor: Richard Vadon Are stage shows aimed at black audiences inclusive or divisive? A West End play about race issues and slavery has announced plans for two performances to be primarily for black audiences. Is the idea inclusive or divisive? |
| 40 | Does Britain Need A Muslim War Memorial? | 20240315 | 20240320 (R4) | Plans announced in the Budget to spend £1 million on a war memorial for Muslim soldiers who died in the two world wars have been applauded by campaigners, but others worry it is singling out one religious group for special treatment. Some have also questioned the timing of the announcement, when the Conservative Party is facing allegations of Islamophobia. What role did Muslims play in the two World Wars? Do other religious groups have their own memorials? And how have monuments like this become flashpoints of the culture wars? Presenter: Adam Fleming Production team: Simon Tulett, Nick Holland, and Ellie House Editor: Penny Murphy Plans for a Muslim war memorial have sparked debate about history, identity and monuments. Plans to spend £1 million of taxpayer cash on a Muslim war memorial have sparked debate about history, identity and monuments. Adam Fleming and guests discuss. |
| 41 | Misgendering And Hate Crime | 20240322 | 20240327 (R4) | Exploring the debate around gender, pronouns, and Scotland's new hate crime law. People online are threatening to report misgendering - for example referring to a trans woman as a man - to the police. They say new Scottish legislation due to come into force in April will make misgendering a criminal offence. What does the new law actually say? What existing laws apply across the UK around misgendering? And does Scotland's new law prioritise trans people over women? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin, Simon Tulett, Ellie House, Paige Neal-Holder Editor: Richard Vadon Exploring the debate around gender, pronouns, and Scotland's new hate crime law. Does Scotland's new law prioritise trans people over women? |
| 42 | Eurovision And Israel | 20240329 | 20240403 | One of the UK's biggest Eurovision parties has been cancelled in protest at Israel's inclusion, so how worthwhile is a boycott of the event as a response to the war in Gaza? The song contest's organisers say the event is non-political, but this isn't the first time global events have had an impact on participation and even lyrics - we chart the key moments. And it's not the first time Israel's participation has sparked debate - a Eurovision expert talks us through the ups and downs of its long association with the event. We'll also hear about the controversy around Israel's song this year and how it's changed, plus the view from the Middle East on what Israelis and Palestinians are saying. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Tulett, Simon Maybin, Ellie House and Paige Neal-Holder Editor: Penny Murphy The war in Gaza prompts calls to boycott this year's song contest. The war in Gaza, and Israel's continued participation in this year's song contest, prompts calls to boycott the event. Adam Fleming and guests explore the debate. |
| 43 | Racism And The Countryside | 20240405 | 20240410 (R4) | Rural parts of the UK have recently been described as 'colonial', predominantly white spaces, where members of ethnic minorities feel unwelcome, sparking a debate about whether the countryside is racist. Data shows that the rural population is 97% white, much more so than in towns and cities, so might that be an explanation for some people feeling out of place? Why has a prominent museum rehung some of its paintings, adding context about the nationalist sentiment some of them might evoke? And how did this debate start in the first place? We track its evolution and the contested evidence at the heart of it. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Tulett, Ellie House, Arlene Gregorius and Ajai Singh Editor: Richard Vadon The UK countryside is very white, but is it racist? The UK countryside has been described as a white, 'colonial' space, that makes ethnic minorities feel unwelcome. But is it racist? Adam Fleming and guests discuss. |
| 44 | Homosexuality And ''sin'' | 20240412 | 20240417 (R4) | The clash between the rights of LGBT people and freedom to express Christian views. An employment tribunal is set to rule on whether a mental health charity in Leeds was right to withdraw a job offer from a Christian social worker who thinks homosexuality is a sin. How can employers - and our legal system - balance the sometimes competing rights of different minority groups? How Christian is Britain these days anyway? And what is minority stress theory??? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Tulett, Simon Maybin, Ellie House, Jameel Shariff Editor: Penny Murphy |
| 45 | Should Cyclists Stay In Their Lane? | 20240419 | 20240424 (R4) | Cyclists shaming drivers online, fights over bike lanes, and the politics of pedal power. TV and radio presenter Jeremy Vine posts a video of a car failing to give way to him while he's riding a penny farthing. Cue angry comments hurling insults and telling him he'd be safer in a car - and sympathetic responses from fellow cyclists. What does the Highway Code actually say about priorities on the roads? What are the stats on cyclists and safety? And how and why has cycling become such a toxic topic? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin, Simon Tulett, Nathan Gower Editor: Richard Vadon |
| 46 | Are Kidults A Problem? | 20240426 | 20240501 (R4) | Harry Potter actor Miriam Margolyes has told adult fans of the franchise to grow up, prompting a discussion about whether younger generations are delaying the responsibilities of adulthood. It's a debate that spans culture and economics, so we look at what the data and the history tell us. Is there evidence that the kidult' is a real phenomenon, where do our ideas of adulthood actually come from, and what on earth is a Disney Adult'? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Tulett, Simon Maybin, Nathan Gower Editor: Penny Murphy Are young people refusing to grow up, or just enjoying harmless escapism? After Harry Potter actor Miriam Margolyes tells adult fans to grow up, we look at the concept of kidults'. Is there anything wrong with a generation growing up later? |
| 47 | Dangers To Women, Man Vs Bear | 20240503 | 20240508 (R4) | Women online are being asked: would you rather be stuck in a forest with a man or a bear? Most are saying they'd choose the bear, saying that men are potentially more dangerous to them than the wild animal. Cue arguments on social media about just how dangerous to women men are. Where did the meme come from? What can crime stats tell us about gender and violence, including sexual violence? And how has the way our society views violence between men and women developed over time? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin, Simon Tulett, Ellie House, Jay Gardner Editor: Richard Vadon |
| 48 | Discipline In Schools | 20240510 | 20240515 (R4) | A photo of a school corridor, showing three posters describing a particular teaching ethos, has started a debate about the right level of discipline in classrooms. Some suggest the instructions, which include sit up', eye contact' and smile', are indicative of a super-strict approach some schools have taken, which might be distressing for children, especially those with special needs. We find out where this approach came from, and hear about the American educator who popularised the all-important acronym SLANT. Supporters of the approach say strict discipline is essential for learning, and that it generates better outcomes. What evidence is there to back this up? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Tulett, Simon Maybin, Ellie House, Jay Gardner Editor: Richard Vadon How strict is too strict, and do tougher schools get better results? How strict is too strict, and do tougher schools get better results? Adam Fleming and guests discuss the best way to educate our children. |
| 49 | Pro-palestinian Student Camps | 20240517 | 20240522 (R4) | The debate about protestors calling for their universities to cut ties with Israel. Encampments of students protesting about Israel's military action in Gaza have been popping up on campuses across the UK. They're calling for their institutions to divest from - sell their stakes in - companies linked to the conflict or Israel, but others say they're demonising the country and stoking antisemitism. How did the movement start and how have universities been responding? What's the history of political activism around university investments? And what does the law say about pitching tents on university land? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin, Simon Tulett, Ellie House, Jameel Shariff |
| 50 | 'anglo-saxon' And Racism | 20240524 | 20240529 (R4) | Should the term Anglo-Saxon?? be dropped because it's been adopted by racists? People online are angry because a history journal has dropped Anglo-Saxon?? from its title. Critics say it is pandering to American academics who are unduly worried about the term being used by white supremacists. The journal says that's got nothing to do with it. It's part of an ongoing debate about whether Anglo Saxon?? is useful and appropriate. How did the argument start? Where did the term actually come from? And how has it been used in modern times to talk about race? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Tulett, Simon Maybin, Natasha Fernandes Editors: Bridget Harney, Sam Bonham Should the term Anglo-Saxon be dropped because it's been adopted by racists? Adam Fleming and guests discuss. |
| 51 | Meat-free Menus And Choice | 20240531 | 20240605 (R4) | Should meat and dairy be taken off menus to help save the planet from climate change? A university is accused of going woke?? after reports it is transitioning to 100% plant-based catering by 2027. Climate activists are calling on universities and other public bodies like councils to ditch animal food products to help tackle the climate crisis. But what did the university in question actually decide and how widespread is the shift to plant-based menus? What's the evidence about the climate impact of meat and dairy versus vegan alternatives? And what is the best way to change people's behaviour when it comes to what they eat? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin, Jordan Dunbar, Ellie House, Natasha Fernandes Editor: Bridget Harney |
| 52 | Counter-protests | 20240816 | 20240821 (R4) | Are counter-protests important for sending a message or can they make confrontation or violence more likely? Is marching in the street a vital expression or is it the wrong place to tackle serious issues? After riots took place outside hotels housing refugees and migrants, counter-protests were swiftly assembled in cities around the UK. They were largely peaceful, but some counter-protesters were arrested and have been charged. Can having two competing sides up the ante and make violence and disorder more likely or is it important two groups of people can be seen to be disagreeing in public? Adam Fleming hears of the history of antifascist counter-protests through history and whether they were effective. He also hears about protest crowd psychology. Guests: Maxine Bowler, Stand up to Racism, Sheffield Andrew Trotter, who was Deputy Assistant Commissioner at the Met Police from 1998-2004 where he had overall command for demonstrations and riots. Professor Nigel Copsey from the University of Teeside Professor Cliff Stott from Keele University who's studied the psychology of crowds Are counter-protests important for sending a message or can they make things worse? Are counter-protests important for sending a message or can they make confrontation more likely? |
| 53 | 'extreme' Misogyny | 20240823 | 20240828 (R4) | Should some forms of misogyny be classed as extremism? After the Government announced it would look at extreme misogyny' in a review of its counter-extremism strategy, a fierce row kicked off on social media. Would creating a category of extreme misogyny' be a long-overdue move, or dangerous overreach that risks labelling young men and boys as radical? We look at the kind of misogynist content the government might be worried about, what the law does and doesn't say about extremism, and how the government's de-radicalisation programme Prevent is already dealing with forms of misogyny. Guests: Ally Fogg, co-founder of the Men & Boys Coalition Dr Charlotte Proudman, barrister and founder of campaign group Right to Equality Dr Joe Whittaker, lecturer in Criminology, Sociology and Social Policy at Swansea University. Jonathan Hall KC, UK's independent reviewer of terrorist legislation Evelina Gibson, former Prevent officer The government is considering classing some kinds of misogyny as extremism - but what could the consequences be? |
| 54 | Accent And Class | 20240830 | 20240904 (R4) | Is it classist to stop Geordies using the term of endearment 'pet'? After the University of Newcastle sent out guidance to researchers advising they avoid using the word 'pet' as it might feel patronising or sexist to women, people took to social media to claim this was a classist move. It sparked a wider discussion about accents and class. Others claimed accents shouldn't be used as a marker of identity and that speaking with Received Pronunciation could be an equalising tool that could prevent prejudice. So what are the origins of RP and what does the data show about our perceptions of accents? GUESTS: Jasmine Andersson, writer and journalist Jonathan Meades, writer and critic Lynda Mugglestone, Professor of the history of English at the University of Oxford Dr Christian Ilbury, lecturer in Socio-linguistics at the University of Edinburgh Is it classist to stop Geordies using the term of endearment 'pet'? Is Received Pronunciation equalising or has it led to discrimination? |
| 55 | Outdoor Smoking Ban | 20240906 | 20240911 (R4) | Is banning smoking outdoors good for our health or state overreach? The Prime Minister has confirmed he's thinking about extending the indoor smoking ban to include outdoor areas restaurant terraces and pub gardens. This, in addition, to plans to progressively increase the age at which you can buy cigarettes so a whole generation never even starts smoking. It's sparked a social media discussion on personal freedom, the nanny state and the removal of civil liberties. But others argued that it would improve health, help the NHS and de-normalise smoking. Adam Fleming asks what does this reaction tell us about attitudes to public health, the collective wellness of a nation and the role of the individual within it? GUESTS Chris Snowdon, Head of Lifestyle Economics at the Institute of Economic Affairs Deborah Arnott Chief Executive of Action on Smoking and Health (ASH) Dr Tessa Langley, health economist specialising in the field of tobacco control, University of Nottingham Virginia Berridge , Professor of History and Health Policy, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine Prof George Davey Smith, Professor of Clinical Epidemiology, Bristol Medical School Is banning smoking outdoors good for our health or an infringement of our civil liberties? |
| 56 | Snow White And The Dwarfism Debate | 20240913 | 20240918 (R4) | Are the seven dwarfs perpetuating dangerous stereotypes or harmless fantasy figures? Disney is remaking its 1937 classic Snow White as a live action film - but this time there's no mention of dwarfs in the title. Game of Thrones actor Peter Dinklage, who has a form of dwarfism, has questioned whether the story should be retold at all, calling it backward. But others argue that it's just a fairytale - and one that can provide valuable work to actors with dwarfism. So how will the remake handle the dwarfs? What is dwarfism and what are the best terms to use? And we take a tour through Hollywood history, from Oompa Loompas to Middle Earth. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin, Phoebe Keane, Ellie House Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Penny Murphy |
| 57 | Coconuts, Race And Hate Speech | 20240920 | 20240925 (R4) | Is it racist for a person of colour to call someone a coconut? Should it be a crime? A teacher was put on trial after she was pictured at a pro-Palestinian march holding a placard that showed then prime minister Rishi Sunak and then home secretary Suella Braverman as coconuts. The term coconut can be used to suggest that someone who is brown on the outside is white on the inside - that they are somehow acting in a way inconsistent with their ethnicity. The prosecution called coconut a racial slur; the judge said the placard was political satire and found the teacher not guilty. How did the case play out in court? What's the history behind this use of the word coconut and others like it? And what does the law say about when speech becomes criminal? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin, Ellie House, Elliot Ryder Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Richard Vadon |
| 58 | Claims Children Are Identifying As Animals | 20240927 | 20241002 (R4) | Are the claims true? What are furries? And is it all really about gender identity? Reports that a school child in Scotland identifies as a wolf have gone viral on social media. Some say stories like it are whipped up to attack trans gender identity; others that they are a sign of gender ideology running rampant in the education system. What do we know about the latest example? The child is said to identify as a furry - what does that mean? And what really happened when a child in south-east England was reported to identify as a cat? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin, Arlene Gregorius, Beth Ashmead Latham, Caroline Bayley Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Richard Vadon |
| 59 | Pop Stars, Boundaries And Toxic Fandom | 20241004 | 20241009 (R4) | Music artists are cancelling gigs to protect their mental health but what do they owe their fans? American singer Chappell Roan pulled out of two appearances at short notice - not for the first time - saying she needed a few days to prioritise her health. Earlier in the summer, she called out fans' creepy behaviour and said abuse and harassment of famous people shouldn't be normalised. Her critics say she's ungrateful and her cancellations cost fans money. But supporters argue she represents a new generation of artists who are no longer willing to put up with the industry's damaging demands. How has Chappell Roan's relationship with fans evolved as her career has taken off? How have radical changes to the music industry's business model affected demands on artists? And what has social media done to the connection between pop stars and their followers? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin, Ellie House, Caroline Bayley Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Richard Vadon Archive: British Pathe; Netflix. Music artists are cancelling gigs to protect their mental health. What do they owe fans? |
| 60 | Breeding For Britain | 20241011 | 20241016 (R4) | Deaths have outnumbered births in the UK for the first time in nearly 50 years, new figures show. Should we encourage people to have more babies? With an ageing population and not enough babies born to fully replace the older generations, some people are warning of population collapse. It was a hot subject at this year's Conservative Party Conference - one fringe meeting discussed how to encourage people to have more children - and the phrase Breed for Britain' was soon trending on X. Some people say that conversations like this are bad for women, and our total population is still growing - thanks to net migration. Others argue that immigration isn't the solution, and we need to increase our fertility rate. What do the figures show about demographic trends? How have other countries tried to boost their birth rates, and have they succeeded? And how has a conspiracy theory about the so-called Great Replacement' shifted into the mainstream? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Ellie House, Simon Maybin, Caroline Bayley Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Penny Murphy |
| 61 | Is Multiculturalism A Strength? | 20250110 | 20250115 (R4) | In the row about child sexual exploitation by gangs - particularly those made up of Pakistani heritage men - some people have begun to question the value of multiculturalism. Shadow Justice Secretary, Robert Jenrick, suggested the law had been applied selectively against grooming gangs 'to sustain the myth that diversity is our strength.' So what do we mean when we talk about multiculturalism in modern Britain, where did the concept first come from, and what is the evidence that it is a source of strength or weakness? Plus, to explore the complexities in this area, we look at the anguish around one particular idea - Islamophobia. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Tulett, Emma Close, Jo Casserly Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Penny Murphy |
| 62 | ''masculine Energy'': Does The Workplace Need More Of It? | 20250117 | 20250122 (R4) | When Mark Zuckerberg appeared on Joe Rogan's podcast last week he said that the corporate world has moved away from masculine energy and is “pretty culturally neutered. ? A culture that 'celebrates aggression' can be positive, he claimed. Does the workplace need more masculine energy? Do businesses need aggression and competitiveness to succeed? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Josephine Casserly, Simon Tulett, Emma Close Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Penny Murphy Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg sparks a row about gender in the workplace. |
| 63 | Mental Health And Race | 20250124 | 20250129 (R4) | Reports that psychology students at a UK university were separated by race to learn about ethnicity and 'whiteness' have prompted a row over racism and mental health. Some of the sessions, The Telegraph claims, were designed for white students to take responsibility for colonialism. King's College London says the sessions have been mischaracterised and that they were open to all students. We dig into what's really been going on, and ask whether separate spaces for different ethnicities are helpful or divisive. Plus, to what extent do mental health services in the UK have a problem with race - we hear the key statistics. And we explore a phrase that keeps coming up in this debate - 'critical race theory'. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Emma Close, Josephine Casserly, Simon Tulett Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Penny Murphy Racism and mental health, safe spaces for ethnic minorities and addressing whiteness. |
| 64 | Bats V Trains | 20250131 | 20250205 (R4) | Do we have to choose between conserving nature and growing the economy? The Chancellor Rachel Reeves has been complaining about the £100m being spent on a tunnel to stop bats being squished by trains on the HS2 railway line. A debate about whether looking after the environment is getting in the way of developing Britain's infrastructure has ensued. Is nature conservation getting in the way of economic growth - and can there only be one winner? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Josephine Casserly, Simon Tulett, Beth Ashmead-Latham Editor: Penny Murphy Production coordinator: Janet Staples Studio engineer: Andy Mills |
| 65 | Surrogacy | 20250207 | 20250212 (R4) | An online debate about whether surrogacy should be allowed was energised this week after actress Lily Collins and her partner announced they had a baby by surrogate on Instagram. In this episode, we explore what surrogacy is like when you're not a celebrity including hearing from woman who was a surrogate for her best friend. In the UK surrogacy is legal but it can't be done for money. We assess calls to change the law and find out where the movement in opposition to surrogacy comes from. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Josephine Casserly, Beth Ashmead Latham and Emma Close Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Penny Murphy Should surrogacy be allowed? An online debate about whether surrogacy should be allowed was energised this week after actress Lily Collins and her partner announced they had a baby by surrogate on Instagram. In this episode, we explore what surrogacy is like when you're not a celebrity including hearing from a woman who was a surrogate for her best friend. In the UK surrogacy is legal but it can't be done for money. We assess calls to change the law and find out where the movement in opposition to surrogacy comes from. |
| 66 | Should Signs Be In English Only? | 20250214 | 20250219 (R4) | This week a Member of Parliament for Reform UK posted a picture of Whitechapel train station in East London. At the entrance of the station, it has the name in English and then also in Bengali. Rupert Lowe MP said: 'The station name should be in English and English only. We'll find out how the station got its bilingual sign and examine the data on immigrants' language skills. How are non-English speakers accommodated in other walks of life? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Charlotte McDonald, Arlene Gregorius and Beth Ashmead Studio manager: Hal Haines. Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Richard Vadon. From train stations to hospitals, is it OK to have signs translated into other languages? From train stations to hospitals, is it okay to have signs translated into other languages? |
| 67 | Nudity - The Great Cover Up? | 20250221 | 20250222 (R4) | How comfortable are we with nudity and why does the naked body still have the power to shock? This month we've seen Bianca Censori break the internet after her red carpet appearance in a transparent dress and artists in north London upset about their life drawing class being moved. What actually happened and why were people so censorious about Bianca? Also, what is the history of nudism in the UK? To discuss the power of the naked body Adam is joined by Dr Victoria Bateman – an economist and author of Naked Feminism: Breaking the cult of female modesty and Stephanie Murray , a freelance journalist and contributing writer for The Atlantic. Presented by Adam Fleming Produced by Emma Close, Beth Ashmead and Clare Williamson Studio manager: Annie Gardiner Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Penny Murphy |
| 68 | Two-tier Justice | 20250418 | 20250423 (R4) | Lucy Connolly is a 42 year old woman from Northampton who is currently serving a custodial sentence for stirring up racial hatred after she posted on X on the day of the Southport attacks last year, calling for 'mass deportations now' and referring to setting fire to asylum hotels. Her case has caused controversy online, with some describing her as a 'political prisoner' and claiming that the justice system is treating some people more harshly than others. But to others, Lucy Connolly is being appropriately punished for an incendiary post at a time of high tensions. Are heftier sentences meted out to some people more than others? Are some groups treated differently in the courts because of their ethnicity or political views? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Josephine Casserly, Simon Maybin and Beth Ashmead-Latham Studio manager: Andy Mills Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Bridget Harney Does the justice system treat some people more harshly than others? News and discussion of consumer affairs |
| 69 | Sex, Gender And The Nhs | 20250425 | 20250430 (R4) | News and discussion of consumer affairs What does the Supreme Court ruling on biological sex mean for the health service? The UK's top court says that under equality law a woman is a biological woman and a man is a biological man. It's sparked discussion about how the NHS accommodates trans people when it comes to single sex spaces, like women-only wards. What do the judgment and equality legislation say about providing services to only one sex? What does NHS policy say and how might it change? And why has the language used by health services become so controversial when it comes to women's health? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Maybin, Josephine Casserly, Bethan Ashmead Latham, Tom Gillett Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Penny Murphy |
| 70 | Gentle Parenting | 20250502 | 20250507 (R4) | News and discussion of consumer affairs A campaign to get verbal abuse on the agenda has sparked debate with headlines that say shouting at children is as bad as physical abuse. What does the evidence actually say about the words we use when speaking to children? Where did the phenomenon of gentle parenting come from, and how do you do it? And who decides how we treat our kids? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Lucy Proctor, Josephine Casserly, Bethan Ashmead Latham, Tom Gillet Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Penny Murphy Parents are arguing online about how we speak to our children. Parents are arguing online about how we speak to our children in the wake of research on shouting. |
| 71 | Disability Benefits | 20250509 | 20250514 (R4) | News and discussion of consumer affairs There's a row in the Labour Party about cutting the benefits paid to disabled people. Ministers say they're trying to manage a budget that's ballooning. That's partly because of more claims from the young and from people with mental health conditions. But others say that these payments are lifelines for people with both mental and physical disabilities. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Josephine Casserly, Viv Jones, Bethan Ashmead-Latham and Tom Gillett Production Coordinator: Janet Staples Studio Engineer: Hal Haines Who should get personal independence payments? |
| 72 | Island Of Strangers? | 20250516 | 20250521 (R4) | News and discussion of consumer affairs As the Prime Minister announced reforms to the UK's immigration system, he warned that without these changes we risk becoming an 'island of strangers'. This has drawn criticism comparing his remarks to historical examples of inflammatory language on immigration. Others say this comparison is unfair and his comments were part of a sensible conversation about immigration. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Bethan Ashmead Latham, Josephine Casserly, Viv Jones and Nik Sindle Editor: Richard Vadon Production Coordinator: Janet Staples Studio Engineer: Hal Haines How careful should politicians be with emotive language on immigration? How do Keir Starmer's remarks on immigration fit into the language used by other politicians, and what is the impact of language? |
| 73 | Grit And Resilience | 20250523 | 20250528 (R4) | News and discussion of consumer affairs The government has launched a new initiative to help teachers address a crisis in mental health among young people and a sharp drop in school attendance since the pandemic. The Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson says she wants schools to teach children greater 'grit and resilience' to handle 'life's ups and downs'. It's the latest in a long line of interventions from education secretaries seeking to encourage the values they think children should be learning in school. Is this the promotion of an important life skill or the latest gimmick burdening teachers? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Josephine Casserly, Viv Jones, Jason Murugesu and Nik Sindle Editor: Penny Murphy Production Coordinator: Janet Staples Studio Engineer: Hal Haines Should schools be teaching children to toughen up? |
| 74 | Banter And Harassment | 20250711 | 20250716 (R4) | News and discussion of consumer affairs An extension of workers' rights, designed to further protect them from harassment on the job, has been criticised as an attack on free speech. The Employment Rights Bill, first tabled in October 2024, would make it an employer's responsibility to prevent harassment of their staff by customers, clients and members of the public, as well as fellow colleagues. Some argue the bill, which is not yet law, would effectively outlaw banter - particularly in settings like pubs - and pressure companies to more closely monitor conversations. Others welcome the plans, arguing that workplace harassment is rife and that banter is often used as an excuse for discriminatory and upsetting behaviour. We go through the proposed changes, look at examples where banter has been used as a defence in court, and explore the origins and evolution of the word itself. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Tulett, Tom Gillett, Nik Sindle Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Penny Murphy New rights designed to protect workers have prompted a row about free speech. Proposed changes to employees' rights, designed to protect them from harassment, have sparked a debate about free speech in the workplace and beyond. |
| 75 | Are Men Being Pushed Out Of Publishing? | 20250718 | 20250723 (R4) | News and discussion of consumer affairs. Just a few years ago the gender gap in book publishing was seen as an issue to address, with many publishing houses focussed on boosting women authors. Has it all gone too far? Are men, especially straight, white men, now being locked out of telling their stories? And what might that mean for society? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Nik Sindle, Lucy Proctor, Tim Gillet Editor: Richard Vadon Many male authors say they are struggling in a female-dominated world. Publishing fiction seems to have become a woman's game - does this matter? |
| 76 | Racism And Prejudice | 20250725 | 20250730 (R4) | News and discussion of consumer affairs The debate around a hierarchy of racism was reignited this week when Labour MP Diane Abbott appeared on a BBC Radio 4 podcast and discussed previous comments she'd made about racism. She maintained there is a difference between racism based on skin colour and other kinds of racism. This sparked conversation around the different types of racism and prejudice faced by Black people, Jewish people, and Gypsy, Roma, and Traveller people. We look at the statistics and discuss the history of the anti-racism movement. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Lucy Proctor, Nik Sindle, Simon Maybin, Natasha Fernandes Editor: Penny Murphy Studio Manager: Hal Haines Is it useful to talk about a hierarchy of racism? Do different groups experience racism in different ways? |
| 77 | Dating And Toxicity | 20250801 | 20250806 (R4) | News and discussion of consumer affairs An app offering women dating safety tools and advice has suspended some of its services following a hack, sparking a debate between the sexes about fairness and respect in dating. Tea, which lets women do background checks on potential male dates, is only available in the USA, but the incident has prompted discussion about similar online groups available in the UK, like 'Are We Dating The Same Guy' on Facebook. Some users say online spaces where they can flag concerns about infidelity or potential abuse are vital for women's wellbeing and safety, but some men feel they are being treated unfairly and that the groups are spreading lies. We spill the tea on the Tea app, look at the laws around what users can and can't say on these groups, and ask whether men really are less trustworthy than women when it comes to dating. Plus, online dating has changed the way we meet potential partners - how has the industry evolved? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Tulett, Lucy Proctor, Nik Sindle, Natasha Fernandes Editor: Penny Murphy Studio Manager: Hal Haines Are women-only dating advice groups doing more harm than good? Women-only apps and online groups for sharing advice about male dates were designed to keep members safe, but are they creating division between the sexes and making dating toxic? |
| 78 | Sydney Sweeney, Jeans And Genes | 20250808 | 20250813 (R4) | A jeans advert featuring the American actress Sydney Sweeney talking about her good genes provoked fierce reaction - and then came the backlash to the backlash. Some people say the advert promotes a eugenicist ideal of blonde hair and blue eyes. Others say it's a sign that the days of diversity in the advertising industry are over. Is 'woke' dead? And what does the controversy tell us about how brands use culture to get our attention? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Tulett, Lucy Proctor, Natasha Fernandes, Mike Wendling Editor: Penny Murphy Production coordinator: Janet Staples Studio engineer: Annie Gardiner Does an advert for jeans signal the end of 'woke'? Does an advert for jeans signal the end of 'woke' or the rise of eugenics? |
| 79 | Asylum Hotels | 20250815 | 20250820 (R4) | News and discussion of consumer affairs Anger has flared outside hotels used to house asylum seekers. Protestors say they are worried about illegal migration, cost to the taxpayer and a lack of consultation, but one issue seems to spark even more concern - the safety of women and children. Opponents have accused protestors of racism and whipping up hate. Is there any evidence that asylum seekers are more likely to commit sexual offences? We trace the clamour for more data to answer that question. Police have been given new guidance on disclosing the ethnicity and nationality of suspects in criminal cases - especially high profile ones. What might be the effect? And why are so many asylum seekers currently housed in hotels anyway? We hear how the system is supposed to work and how it's evolved. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Tulett, Natasha Fernandes, Emma Close and Tom Gillett Editor: Penny Murphy Production coordinator: Janet Staples Studio engineer: Annie Gardiner Protestors outside asylum hotels say they fear for the safety of women and children. Some protestors outside asylum hotels say they fear for the safety of women and children in surrounding areas. Opponents say they are racist. Adam Fleming and guests discuss. |
| 80 | What Is Patriotism? | 20251003 | 20251008 (R4) | ![]() It seems like everyone wants to be a patriot this week, from Prime Minister Keir Starmer to people hoisting flags up British lampposts. But what does patriotism really mean? At the Labour Party conference there was lots of talk of 'progressive patriotism' - a definition of the term that emphasises Britain's tolerance and multiculturalism. Others invoke patriotism when seeking a return to the past. Others reject the word entirely because of its links to nationalism. We find out why Keir Starmer and the Labour Party are trying to formulate 'progressive patriotism', examine the history of the concept going back to the ancient Greeks, and ask what polling tells us about how patriotic British people feel. Presenter: Adam Fleming Production team: Lucy Proctor, Natasha Fernandes, Mike Wendling, Tom Gillet Studio manager: Andy Mills Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Bridget Harney The battle to define patriotism in the UK. The Labour Party is promoting 'progressive patriotism' - does the concept make sense? News and discussion of consumer affairs |
| 81 | Angry Middle-aged White Men | 20251010 | 20251015 (R4) | ![]() Football pundit and former Manchester United star Gary Neville posted a video that he pitched as a call to national unity. But was greeted by a wave of online vitriol for one line in which he blamed “angry middle-aged white men ? for creating political division. Many middle-aged white men took to social media – to deny they are angry, to describe their anger as justified, or to call Neville's comments the out-of-touch ramblings of a “champagne socialist ?. But the footballer has his supporters too, with some saying he put his finger on a specific group that has been pulling at the fault lines of British politics by hoisting flags and protesting against immigration. What do polling and history tell us about the political divides within our society – and when it comes to our political divisions, who's really to blame? Presenter: Adam Fleming Production team: Emma Close, Natasha Fernandes, Mike Wendling Studio manager: Andy Mills Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Richard Vadon Are they dividing the country? Was Gary Neville right when he said 'angry middle-aged white men' are responsible for Britain's political divisions? News and discussion of consumer affairs |
| 82 | Graffiti, Church, And Western Civilisation | 20251017 | 20251022 (R4) | ![]() An art exhibition in Canterbury Cathedral has enraged traditionalists who believe that it doesn't fit with the holy site's beauty or the church's mission. The works consist of a set of temporary vinyl stickers with questions like “Why did you create hate when love is by far more powerful? ? and “Does our struggle mean anything? ? The questions for God were devised after artist Alex Vellis and curator Jacquiline Creswell consulted a series of marginalised groups. The organisers say the stickers were tested to make sure they did not damage the cathedral's ancient walls. But they have faced criticism on artistic grounds and questions about the appropriateness of the art and the values behind it. Among the outraged were Vice President JD Vance, who called the stickers “ugly ?, and Elon Musk, who called it an affront to western civilisation They in turn were faced with supporters of the exhibition who argued it reflected the church's mission and spread a message of inclusiveness and tolerance. Art has always been intrinsically tied to religion and the Anglican Church, so how far back does this culture war battle really go – and why did political leaders in America jump into the controversy? Presenter: Adam Fleming Production team: Natasha Fernandes, Ellie House, Mike Wendling Studio manager: Andy Mills Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Richard Vadon Does a modern art exhibition belong in Canterbury Cathedral? A modern art exhibition has offended some traditionalists. Does it belong in Canterbury Cathedral? |
| 83 | Racism And Reparations | 20251024 | 20251029 (R4) | ![]() News and discussion of consumer affairs Sir Lenny Henry has called for the UK government to pay £18tn in slavery reparations for its role in the transatlantic slave trade, and argued that every black Briton also deserves compensation. The comedian, co-author of a new book titled The Big Payback, says the payments would help repair damage caused in parts of the Americas, especially the Caribbean, and argues slavery has contributed to modern day racism and poorer outcomes for black people in the UK. Opponents have argued it's unfair to hold modern Britons responsible for past wrongs and called the £18tn figure absurd and divisive - we find out where that figure came from, and what calculations went into it. Many in this debate point out that, although Britain profited from slavery, it also abolished it - we look at the reasons behind that shift and what it meant for slaves and slave owners. Plus, reparations used to be all about wars - how else have they been applied throughout history? Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Simon Tulett, Mike Wendling, Natasha Fernandes Editor: Richard Vadon Production coordinator: Janet Staples Studio engineer: Andrew Mills Does the UK government owe \u00a318tn in compensation for slavery? Sir Lenny Henry has called for the UK government to pay £18tn in slavery reparations, but is it justified, and would it improve race relations? |
| 84 | Women's Safety And Public Transport | 20251031 | 20251105 (R4) | ![]() News and discussion of consumer affairs. A petition calling for women-only tube carriages has surpassed 12,000 signatures. It comes amid increased reports of sexual offences on public transport, both in London and beyond. Supporters claim that giving women the option to travel separately from men will make them safer, and send a message that harassment is unacceptable. Critics argue that this is a backwards step, amounting to segregation. Some say it unfairly stigmatises men. We hear from the woman leading the campaign, and explore the history of single-sex train carriages in the UK. Does the data show that sexual harassment on trains is on the rise, or are the figures a symptom of increased reporting? What do we know about other public safety campaigns attempting to tackle sexual harassment and violence over the years - and do they point us towards better solutions? Presenter: Adam Fleming Production team: Ellie House, Natasha Fernandes, Tom Gillett, and Bob Howard Studio manager: Andrew Mills Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Penny Murphy Should we bring back women's-only train carriages to prevent sexual harassment? A petition calling for women-only tube carriages has surpassed 10,000 signatures, and sparked a debate about protecting women from sexual harassment on public transport. |
| 85 | Are Women Better Off Single? | 20251107 | ![]() News and discussion of consumer affairs An article in British Vogue asking if it's 'embarrassing' to have a boyfriend prompts a discussion about whether women might be better off ditching men and staying single. Some women say they feel more empowered by single life, and that they expect much higher standards of men these days. Others think it's divisive to suggest men are, on average, poor relationship material and that it's unfair to demean women who are happy with a partner. We speak to author of the British Vogue article, Chanté Joseph, to find out what prompted it and what it revealed. The image of single women in society has a long, and largely negative, history - we open the archives on cat ladies and old maids. And who's happier anyway - single women or those in relationships? We look at the available data. Presenter: Adam Fleming Production team: Simon Tulett, Natasha Fernandes, Paul Moss, Marie Lennon Studio manager: Andrew Mills Production coordinator: Gemma Ashman Editor: Penny Murphy A viral article on relationships sparks a row about whether women are better off single. A viral article about boyfriends and relationships sparks a row about whether women are better off being single. Adam Fleming and guests discuss. An article about 'embarrassing' boyfriends prompts a debate over women's singledom | |
| 86 | Bikinis And Ai | 20260109 | 20260114 (R4) | ![]() Elon Musk's social networking site X has restricted access to one of the features on its artificial intelligence chat-bot called Grok, because of a global outcry. It allows users to alter photos, for example changing a person's clothes - without their permission. With a simple instruction a man's trousers can become swimming trunks -- and more frequently -- a woman can be made to wear a bikini. The platform faced a backlash with governments around the world calling for urgent action and some politicians calling for X to be banned. We hear from someone whose image was manipulated without her consent and from someone who uses it in her business career. So is A.I. image manipulation a force for good or not? Presenter: Adam Fleming Production team: Emma Close, Natasha Fernandes and Tom Gillett Studio manager: Andrew Mills Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Penny Murphy Should image manipulation be allowed? Adam Fleming helps you work out what the culture wars are really about. |
| 87 | Men And Loneliness | 20260116 | 20260121 (R4) | ![]() A podcast conversation between the entrepreneur Steven Bartlett and the gamer-turned psychiatrist-turned-online self help guru Dr K has gone viral. And it's about what might happen if men can't get a date. The podcast was originally published last summer but more recently re-surfaced clips have sparked a debate online about how far society should go to help men who are struggling to find a partner. Should we have sympathy for men who can't get a date? We hear from an intimacy coach who helps men and couples navigate the dating world and from a talent manager and content creator who makes videos about feminism, being single and child free. Presenter: Adam Fleming Production team: Emma Close, Natasha Fernandes and Tom Gillett Studio manager: Hal Haines Production coordinator: Janet Staples Editor: Penny Murphy Should society intervene to help lonely men? Resurfaced clips from a podcast conversation have sparked online debate around whether society should intervene to help lonely men. Adam Fleming helps you work out what the culture wars are really about. |
| 88 | The Traitors And Unconscious Bias | 20260123 | 20260128 (R4) | ![]() Adam Fleming helps you work out what the culture wars are really about. The UK's most popular TV show, The Traitors, has come under the spotlight not just because of its popularity but because it has been accused of reflecting prejudice in British society. The charge is that contestants from ethnic minorities are more likely to be expelled early on in the game because of unconscious bias, particularly unconscious racial bias. Others shows too, like Strictly Come Dancing, Love Island and Big Brother have faced similar accusations. Adam Fleming unpicks the debate. Presenter: Adam Fleming Production team: Charlotte McDonald, Natasha Fernandes and John Murphy Studio manager: Andrew Mills Production coordinator: Gemma Ashman Editor: Penny Murphy Are contestants on the TV show guilty of unconscious bias? Are the contestants on the TV show guilty of unconscious bias? |
| 89 | Child-free Spaces | 20260130 | 20260204 (R4) | ![]() Adam Fleming helps you work out what the culture wars are really about. Should we have more child-free spaces? The French state railway company has introduced child-free carriages on some of its high-speed trains. This has caused a row online. Adam Fleming gets to the bottom of the story and asks if there is a growing demand for more child-free spaces. But is the debate simply a measure of growing intolerance - particularly of children - in society. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Natasha Fernandes, Tom Gillett, John Murphy Studio manager: Andrew Mills Production co-ordinator: Gemma Ashman Series Editor: Penny Murphy Adam Fleming asks, should we have more child-free spaces? Are we becoming less tolerant? |
| 90 | The Nostalgia Divide | 20260206 | 20260211 (R4) | ![]() Adam Fleming helps you work out what the culture wars are really about. Peace talks for the culture wars. Nostalgia and the cringe factor. Adam Fleming explores why 2016 is big online, especially for Gen Z. Can you really be nostalgic for things you didn't really experience. With the help of others, Adam unpicks what nostalgia is and where it came from. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: Natasha Fernandes, Tom Gillett and John Murphy Studio Manager: Andrew Mills Editor: Penny Murphy In an era of polarisation, propaganda, and pile-ons, Adam Fleming helps you work out what the culture wars are really about. This week it's nostalgia and cringe. |
| 91 | Who Is Heathcliff? | 20260213 | 20260218 (R4) | ![]() Adam Fleming helps you work out what the culture wars are really about. Peace talks for the culture wars. The latest version of Wuthering Heights has come in for criticism on social media, especially about the casting of a white actor as Heathcliff. Chris Warburton and guests examine the debate about representation on the big screen. Presenter: Chris Warburton Producers: Natasha Fernandes, Tom Gillett, John Murphy Studio Manager: Andrew Mills Production co-ordinator: Gemma Ashman Editor: Penny Murphy Should Heathcliff be played by a white actor? Chris Warburton and guests examine the latest Wuthering Heights film and arguments that Heathcliff should not be played by a white actor. |
| 92 | Looksmaxxing | 20260220 | 20260225 (R4) | ![]() Adam Fleming helps you work out what the culture wars are really about. Peace talks for the culture wars. Adam looks at the dark art of looksmaxxing, asking what is it, where does it come from and why has it been growing online? Adam gets a glossary of the terms around this trend. He hears how social media is influencing beauty standards. And we find out about 'pretty privilege. Presenter: Adam Fleming Producers: John Murphy, Natasha Fernandes and Annabel Deas. Studio manager: Jack Wilfan Production co-ordinator: Gemma Ashman Editor: Penny Murphy The dark art of looksmaxxing, and why it has been trending online. Adam Fleming explores the dark art of looksmaxxing - what is it, where does it come from, and why has it been growing online? |
| 93 | The Guides And Single Sex Organisations | 20260410 | 20260415 (R4) | ![]() The organising body of the Girl Guides says that trans girls - biological males - will have to leave by the 6th September to conform with a ruling by the Supreme Court last year. Whatever the perceived rights and wrongs of this decision, it's another chapter in the debate about whether we need single sex groups at all, from the Brownies to the gentleman's club. We look into the history of the Girl Guides and the Scouts; hear what the law says about single sex organisations and ask whether girls really do better when boys aren't around? Presenter: Adam Fleming Production team: Lucy Proctor, Simon Tullet and Tom Gillett Studio manager: Andrew Mills Production coordinator: Gemma Ashman Editor: Richard Vadon The Girl Guides says that trans girls will have to leave but do we need single sex groups? The Girl Guides says that trans girls will have to leave by the 6th of September to conform with a ruling by the Supreme Court last year. But do we need single sex groups at all? |
| 94 | Super Skinny Celebs | 20260417 | 20260422 (R4) | ![]() Should we call out celebrities we deem too thin, or just leave them alone? That's the debate prompted by an apparent shift among A-list stars - mostly women - to lose weight. Some people say it's a worrying trend, fuelled by weight loss drugs, that's damaging women's views of their bodies. Others say it's none of our business what these celebs look like, and that they are the product of a culture that still prizes thinness. We hear about some of the most prominent celebs to hit the headlines recently, find out what 'body positivity' really means, and explore how some in this debate are linking body shapes to politics. Presenter: Adam Fleming Production team: Simon Tulett, Annabel Deas and Ellie House Studio manager: Andrew Mills Production coordinator: Gemma Ashman Editor: Richard Vadon What does Hollywood's ultra-thin trend mean for body positivity? What does Hollywood's ultra-thin trend mean for body positivity? Adam Fleming and guests discuss. |
| 95 | Is The Uk A Christian Country? | 20260424 | 20260429 (R4) | ![]() A report by a Christian charity, suggesting a surge in churchgoing is withdrawn due to faulty data, but some Christians in the UK still believe in the finding that there is a 'quiet revival'. Others point to recent data showing the steep decline in Christianity. We get into the story of the report and ask whether data and our institutions can tell us just how Christian the UK really is. Presenter: Adam Fleming Production team: Annabel Deas, Simon Tulett and Ellie House Studio manager: Andrew Mills Production coordinator: Gemma Ashman Editor: Penny Murphy A report suggesting a spike in church attendance reignites a long-standing debate. A report suggesting a spike in church attendance reignites a long-standing debate. Adam Fleming and guests discuss. |
| 96 | 20260501 | 20260506 (R4) | ![]() | |
| 97 | 20260508 | 20260513 (R4) | ![]() | |
| 98 | 20260515 | 20260520 (R4) | ![]() |
